Considering Automotive School? The Greenest Car of the Year Is…
Imagine a “green” car. What pops into your mind? Most likely, it’s a sleek electric vehicle (EV) silently gliding down the road, leaving no fumes or emissions in its wake. Automotive school has seen over 50 EV models now available in the US, so the electric revolution seems unstoppable. But hold on a minute—a new report throws a curveball.
The American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE), a non-profit that has analyzed car pollution for decades, has crowned the Toyota Prius Prime SE the “greenest” car for 2024. This plug-in hybrid (PHEV) surprises many, as it can travel 44 miles on electricity before switching to a hybrid mode.
Why the Prius Prime Wins the Green Race
The secret to Prius Prime’s success lies in its overall efficiency, according to Peter Huether of ACEEE. It’s the lightweight design, advanced technology, and overall weight optimization that makes all Prius models eco-friendly, he explains. The Prius Prime isn’t the first PHEV to top the GreenerCars list, having won in 2020 and 2022.
This staying power of PHEVs highlights a crucial point: simply being electric isn’t enough for a car to be truly “green.” Weight, battery size, and overall efficiency all play a role.
As we often emphasize in automotive school, while a massive electric truck might seem better than a gas-guzzler of the same size, both pale compared to a smaller, efficient gas-powered car. This is because larger vehicles, electric or not, require more resources to manufacture and have a bigger impact on reaching emissions reduction goals.
The GreenerCars Analysis: Beyond Tailpipe Emissions
The GreenerCars report takes a comprehensive approach, analyzing 1,200 cars available in 2024. It considers not just tailpipe emissions while driving but also the environmental impact of manufacturing cars and batteries. It even assesses pollutants beyond carbon dioxide, including nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide, and particulate matter – all harmful to human health.
Each car receives a “green score” from 0 to 100 based on these factors. The Prius Prime, scoring 71, edges out several fully electric cars like the Nissan Leaf and Mini Cooper SE (both in the high 60s). Even the Toyota RAV4 Prime, a PHEV SUV with 42 miles of electric range, scores a respectable 64. Notably, a single-gas hybrid, the Hyundai Elantra Blue, makes the list due to its efficient design and excellent fuel economy.
Automotive School Explores Plug-in Hybrids: A Middle Ground in the Race to Electrification
Often overlooked in the rush towards EVs, PHEVs offer a compromise. They can run on electric power for 20-50 miles, allowing drivers to complete most daily commutes emission-free. Then, a gas engine kicks in for longer trips. This avoids the current limitations of Canada’s developing charging infrastructure, a significant concern for many drivers.
The Prius Prime’s superior ranking stems from its small battery, minimizing manufacturing emissions and resource consumption. As you’ll discover in hybrid and electrical mechanic training, its battery is a fraction of the size of behemoths like the Hummer EV, translating to fewer emissions and less reliance on rare earth mineral extraction.
The Challenge of Real-World Driving Habits
However, the GreenerCars report’s findings hinge on an assumption: Prius Prime drivers utilize electric power for over 50% of their driving. While this may be true for drivers with convenient home charging, studies suggest many PHEV owners use them primarily as regular hybrids, rarely plugging them in. This undermines the report’s conclusions.
Some experts, like Gil Tal of the University of California, Davis, believe fully electric cars are always the better option, especially as renewables like wind and solar power become increasingly integrated into the grid, making electric cars even cleaner over time.
Do you want to become a hybrid and electric vehicle mechanic?
Contact ATC Montreal for more information.
